Star Trek: The Original Series 1-14: Balance of Terror

Episode:

14

|

Writer:

Paul Schneider

|

Director:

Vincent McEveety

|

Air Date:

15-Dec-1966

---

This week on Sci-Fi Adventures, I'm watching classic Star Trek: The Original Series episode Balance of Terror, from halfway through season 1. It's maybe a bit of a weird choice, seeing as the last episode I wrote about was the season 2 finale Assignment: Earth, but I have my reasons. Also by pure coincidence, it's the next episode alphabetically. That's the last of the A titles and this is the first of the Bs.

Speaking of titles, this and Encounter at Farpoint must have the two dullest looking title cards in Star Trek. Though I suppose it's thematically appropriate not to see anything. The title itself is also appropriate to the episode as a 'balance of terror' is when two opposing nations have an equal capacity for destruction on a horrifying scale, and a fear of retaliation keeps them from going to war.

I'm going to be watching the remastered version with the new CGI effects and I'll be curious to see how it compares to the other episodes I've written about, as this was the very first one to get the remastering treatment. They got it released on 16th September 2006, just a week late for the show's 40th anniversary.

I'm also going to be writing words under my screencaps and I'm basically going to give SPOILERS for every moment of the story. I may even spoil some things from earlier episodes as well, but nothing released after 15th December 1996. I mean within reason. I may mention a few things about Enterprise.

Star Trek: The Original Series 1-03: Where No Man Has Gone Before

Episode:

3

|

Writer:

Samuel A. Peeples

|

Director:

James Goldstone

|

Air Date:

22-Sep-1966

---

This week on Sci-Fi Adventures, I'm watching the third episode of Star Trek: The Original Series: Where No Man Has Gone Before. It's also the second and the first, depending on how you look at it.

Sometimes people use the term 'pilot episode' to refer to the first released episode of a series, but this story was a true pilot, created to prove the concept and get Star Trek green lit. In fact it was the second pilot, produced after The Cage failed to win executives over. Getting two pilots like this was unusual, probably still is. When Desilu (the studio) originally came to NBC (the network) they'd offered them a choice of four story concepts and NBC picked the hardest one, so they felt like they were partly to blame for it not working out like they'd hoped.

So the Star Trek folks came up with some new options for the executives to choose from: three scripts titled Mudd's Women, The Omega Glory and Where No Man Has Gone Before. All three stories were put into production eventually, with Mudd's Women being regarded as one of the worst episodes of season 1, and The Omega Glory one of the worst in season 2. Fortunately Where No Man Has Gone Before was the script chosen for the second pilot, and it got the job done, earning Star Trek its first season.

It takes a while to get a TV series going though, so they ended up sitting on the finished episode for over a year. The episode ended up airing as the third story in season one, after The Man Trap and Charlie X, which is a bit weird as it features different characters and uniforms to the episodes before and after it. It does have the same premise as Charlie X though to be fair, so the story would've been familiar enough. Also at this point 66.7% of all Star Trek episodes featured the word 'man' in the title, down from 100% a couple of episodes ago. At the time of writing Trek would have to release another 550 episodes with 'man' in the name to get the percentage back up to where it was this week in 1966.

I'd give you some more facts, like how the cinematographer, Earnest Haller, had won an Oscar for Gone with the Wind and was pulled out of retirement for one last job, but I think I've proven by now that I've read the Wikipedia page.

Okay I'm going to go through the whole episode now commenting on basically everything, so this review is going to have SPOILERS. I'll not spoil anything that aired after it however, no matter how many Gary Mitchells or galactic barriers it has.

Star Trek: The Original Series 1-01: The Man Trap

Episode:

1

|

Writer:

George Clayton Johnson

|

Director:

Marc Daniels

|

Air Date:

08-Sep-1966

---

It's Star Trek Day today, September 8th, so to celebrate I've decided to rewatch The Man Trap, the very first ever episode of Star Trek! Well... maybe. It's arguably not even the first with 'Man' in the title.

The Man Trap was the sixth episode of The Original Series to be filmed and it's at least the fourth chronologically (after The Cage, Where No Man Has Gone Before and The Corbomite Maneuver). But it's undisputedly the first Trek story to air on televisions and it aired exactly 55 years ago today, so that's why I'm writing about it. Well okay it aired two days earlier in Canada, but no one counts that for some reason.

There were a few reasons why this episode was chosen to get moved to the front of the line, such as: it has the characters down on a strange new world instead of being bottled up on the ship, it doesn't include any "space hookers", it's got a straightforward story, the visual effects could be completed on time, and it has a scary space monster. Uh, spoilers, sorry. Basically they wanted to put their best foot forward to maximise their chances that viewers would come back for a second story.

It was directed by Marc Daniels, who was credited on 14 episodes over three seasons, leaving him tied with Joseph Pevney as the series' most prolific director. On the other hand this was writer George Clayton Johnson's only Trek story. He wrote a bunch of Twilight Zone though and co-wrote the novel Logan's Run, so he wasn't the worst choice for the job! In fact the Star Trek producers made a habit of trying to get acclaimed science fiction authors to write for the series... and then heavily rewriting them afterwards to make their stories feel like Trek. The writers weren't always impressed.

Okay, I'm going to go through the whole episode one scene at a time, writing a recap under my screencaps and sharing my thoughts along the way. This means that there'll be SPOILERS for this episode and every single other Trek episode that aired before it. All zero of them.

Doctor Who: The Second Doctor Era (1966-1969)

Today on Sci-Fi Adventures, I'm still dealing with the horrifying consequences of my past decisions!

My first mistake was to watch (almost) all of classic Doctor Who over eight weeks during Twitch's marathon. Actually, I'm kind of not regretting that even though it was very much not the way these stories were intended to be watched. My second mistake came afterwards when I let my brain even entertain the possibility of writing a short review for each and every serial I'd watched. That's the kind of thing you really want to prepare for while you're watching them or better still never because that's a lot of words, man. But I figured it was either now or never, I ain't watching them all again.

So I've written down what I remember thinking about the Second Doctor's serials, the ones that Twitch showed anyway (plus a couple of bonus stories). That's 13 whole reviews in one article, some of them more than a couple of paragraphs long! In fact, I'll even throw in an extra opinion right now: I like the way the new title sequence tears apart to reveal the Doctor's face, it's a clever effect. Not sure the plain logo's much of an upgrade though, but I guess they needed to keep it simple to make the video effects work.

There's going to be SPOILERS all over the place, but my plan is to only spoil things that happened either during the episode I'm reviewing, or the ones that came before it. So if you're reading about Tomb of the Cybermen you'll get no spoilers for The War Games, but I might spoil something about The Tenth Planet.

Doctor Who: The First Doctor Era (1963-1966)

I realise that I've been slacking a little bit when it comes to this sci-fi review site of mine. "Next on Sci-Fi Adventures I'll be writing about Deep Space Nine's Rivals," is basically what I said at the end of my last post, and then I disappeared entirely for six months.

What happened was that I got distracted with other things, some of them important, some of them less so. Like that Doctor Who marathon that Twitch was showing a couple of months back for instance. Until then my exposure to the classic series had been pretty pitiful, I'd seen maybe two stories from each Doctor, so I'd always felt like I'd missed out on an important part of British pop culture and there was a gaping hole in my sci-fi knowledge. Then Twitch announced it was showing the entire classic series (more or less) for free over two months and I figured it was an opportunity I couldn't miss. In fact, I even watched some of the stories that they skipped, if there was anything still surviving of them to watch.

Turns out that 8 weeks of 16 episodes a night is actually quite a lot to sit through. But I somehow made it through and my evenings were finally my own again. Then I had my second bad idea!

I had no intention to write about any of the serials for Sci-Fi Adventures because I wouldn't be able to rewind to the stories to check things, getting good screencaps would be a pain, and there was something like 140 of them, so I didn't bother writing up proper notes, or coming up with reviews as I went along. But then afterwards it occurred to me that this was it, I'm never going watch all these stories again, this was my one and only chance to ever write about the whole of classic Doctor Who like this. So I've gone and written mini-reviews of every story I watched using whatever notes and screencaps I did take, the chatlog of conversations I had while watching, and anything that was left in my brain after a few months. I can definitely relate to the Doctor's memory problems now; a lot of the series is still in there but it took a bit of prodding to come out.

What you'll find below are my first 19 reviews covering the whole Hartnell era. I didn't write a synopsis for any of them but I did include some SPOILERS. I'll only be spoiling up to the serial you're currently reading though, so I'm not going to go into a rant about Dodo or whatever midway through The Aztecs.